Skip to main content
Question

How do I file a damage claim with airbnb while avoiding a retaliatory review?

  • Nov 18, 2026 4:09 AM UTC
  • 6 replies
  • 49 views

EmberAndOar
New Participant
Forum|alt.badge.img

Bottom line: the guest stained my ceiling by several of those stretchy-sticky hand kid toys stuck to our ceiling that when we pulled them off, they ALL left a stain in the color of the different hands on the ceiling.  You cannot just paint one section of a ceiling - the paint never matches and I don’t have the original paint to even attempt it.  So, I need to paint the entire ceiling.  They also stained my carpet unabashedly by leaving a pile of ramen noodles in the middle of the carpet without even attempting to clean it up.

 

Now, I have this evidence today - on their check-out day.  And I know generally it is advisable to avoid posting negative reviews of guests until right before the 14 day window expires, but how do I handle this situation where I have my next guests coming in a few days, well ahead of the 14 day window?  I don’t want there to be any question as to who damaged the ceiling.  So, ideally I’d like to somehow submit the evidence to airbnb immediately, then go out to get quotes for repainting the ceiling, and then only right before the 14 day window reach out to the guests requesting payment for painting the ceiling.

 

Is there a guidebook or generally considered best way to go about seeking reimbursement for damages from an airbnb guest?  Any advice is much appreciated!

 

PS: these guests were pretty awful. 

  1. They booked my property under a first guest and held the reservation until close to when my refund policy would no longer fully refund them, then they canceled and rebooked under a second guest name.   But, “luckily” for them, they then got to benefit from my last-minute pricing.  Because the first reservation showed many of the guests in the party, and because the reservation was an unusual 6-day booking of Wednesday until Tuesday and the second booking was for the exact same dates, I was able to determine that the second group was actually the same as the first group.  I need to register all guests with my HOA.  When I asked the person that booked the second reservation to provide the guest names, she was hesitant and asked if and why I need all guest names - she was trying to hide those names so I wouldn’t see the overlap.  This second guest did, in fact, confirm they were the same group as a part of the story I’ll cut out here.
  1. Morning #1 of the stay, the guest messages me that the hot water isn’t working.  I send over my property manager.  Magically there’s hot water and as it turns out she didn’t even both to check that 5 people in a row took showers in the morning before her.
  2. Later, same morning, she requests more dishwasher pods.  They were staying for 6 days and we left out 10 pods.  We also indicate that anything beyond what we supply is guest responsibility to bring.  So, in 1 day she apparently uses all 10 pods.  Regardless, I want to be a good host so I send the property manager back again and he grabs another handful of pods. She scoffs at this saying it’ll only last 1 more day, so he just gives her our entire supply.  Then, she tacks on that she’s already done 5 loads of laundry so she will need more laundry pods.  He again grabs her a handful, she again scoffs, he again leaves her our entire supply.  Ultimately, they “used” about 40 dishwasher and 40 laundry pods.  They also told my property manager that they also have an airbnb property and that our place is too expensive to not give them all they want.  So, they also are aware of how much guests like them suck.
  3. The next morning they complained that the vacuum we left didn’t work well and asked for a better one.  So, my property manager brought over another and then they left the floors absolutely covered in dirt, leaves, and food everywhere.
  4. They left all of the lights on in the house (in house check-out instructions to turn off), all heat turned to max (also in instructions to turn down), and just a ton of messes all over.  Our dirtiest guest in my ~14 months hosting.

6 replies

Joe Dela Seda
Hospitable Team Member
Forum|alt.badge.img
  • Hospitable Team Member
  • Nov 18, 2026 6:32 AM UTC

Hello, ​@EmberAndOar. That sounds like a really frustrating experience!

I would suggest filing your AirCover claim as soon as possible rather than waiting until day 13. The timing of your review and damage claim are separate matters.

If you're based in the US, Hospitable also offers Guest Damage Insurance, with claims filed directly through Hospitable and no need to contact the guest.

You can learn more here: Guest Damage Insurance

I'd also recommend keeping your communication with guests polite and factual.

I'd love to hear from other hosts, too! How do you usually handle guest damage claims? Any tips you'd like to share?


Derek Jones
Hospitable Team Member
Forum|alt.badge.img+3
  • Hospitable Team Member
  • Nov 18, 2026 10:14 AM UTC

​@EmberAndOar filing the Aircover usually requires attempting to collect from the guest first and only after they have not responded or declined can you proceed with the Aircover claim. 

First, make sure you delay their review until the last minute! You can do this in Hospitable. Go to the Pending Reviews section:https://my.hospitable.com/gx/reviews/pending , click the pending review, click to leave them a 1 star, scroll down, click the ‘Delay until last minute’ and this will wait literally until the last second of the 14 day review period. 

And make sure you leave them an accurate 1 star review. Keep it factual so the guest doesn’t have a chance to get yours removed (these days Airbnb seems to remove host reviews so easy). 

Hosts handle this different ways. The way I would handle this is put all the evidence in the message thread with the guest. Let them know mistakes and accidents can happen, but that they broke multiple house rules; list them (the place was left dirty, etc) and provide the photo evidence. ask how they would like to handle the situation. I ask this before i ask them to pay or file a Resolution Center request.

My approach is to get them to say something that will give me confidence that their review will be removed. For example, they usually lash out and say ‘we didn’t do that, we’re going to leave you a bad review’ or sometimes they are aloof enough to say they will leave a good review if you just let it slide. In my experience guests who are stupid enough to do the things you mentioned are also not savvy and will react in the message thread to your advantage when confronted.  Airbnb review rules have a removal reason for retaliation and the requirement is that you let the guest know they broke a house rule and they retaliate so be very clear that they broke house rules and point to them.

Hope this helps. sorry you had a guest that enjoyed eating dish pods.

PS - we launched Protect which has guest damage insurance on a per reservation basis. Claims are filed without contacting the guest or the booking channel. https://my.hospitable.com/property-protection
 


EmberAndOar
New Participant
Forum|alt.badge.img
  • Author
  • New Participant
  • Nov 18, 2026 1:44 PM UTC

​@EmberAndOar filing the Aircover usually requires attempting to collect from the guest first and only after they have not responded or declined can you proceed with the Aircover claim. 

First, make sure you delay their review until the last minute! You can do this in Hospitable. Go to the Pending Reviews section:https://my.hospitable.com/gx/reviews/pending , click the pending review, click to leave them a 1 star, scroll down, click the ‘Delay until last minute’ and this will wait literally until the last second of the 14 day review period. 

And make sure you leave them an accurate 1 star review. Keep it factual so the guest doesn’t have a chance to get yours removed (these days Airbnb seems to remove host reviews so easy). 

Hosts handle this different ways. The way I would handle this is put all the evidence in the message thread with the guest. Let them know mistakes and accidents can happen, but that they broke multiple house rules; list them (the place was left dirty, etc) and provide the photo evidence. ask how they would like to handle the situation. I ask this before i ask them to pay or file a Resolution Center request.

My approach is to get them to say something that will give me confidence that their review will be removed. For example, they usually lash out and say ‘we didn’t do that, we’re going to leave you a bad review’ or sometimes they are aloof enough to say they will leave a good review if you just let it slide. In my experience guests who are stupid enough to do the things you mentioned are also not savvy and will react in the message thread to your advantage when confronted.  Airbnb review rules have a removal reason for retaliation and the requirement is that you let the guest know they broke a house rule and they retaliate so be very clear that they broke house rules and point to them.

Hope this helps. sorry you had a guest that enjoyed eating dish pods.

PS - we launched Protect which has guest damage insurance on a per reservation basis. Claims are filed without contacting the guest or the booking channel. https://my.hospitable.com/property-protection
 

 

I really appreciate this advice.  I think generally this would be a good strategy, but in this case I’m hesitant:  1) because they already demonstrated they are savvy by booking-cancelling-then rebooking to tie up my listing and then still get the last minute discount, and 2) they said they are airbnb owners themselves, so I think they’d again be savvy enough to navigate this to not say anything regrettable in the chat.  All of this just makes me nervous about initiating anything that makes them aware of my unhappiness before their ability to leave a negative review expires.


Jilly
Known Participant
Forum|alt.badge.img
  • Known Participant
  • Nov 18, 2026 5:05 PM UTC

I wait until day 13 to contact the Guest about damage/broken rules via Resolution Center, and I set my review to post at the last-minute (then I block their profile in Airbnb so they can’t communicate with me or book anymore). I’ve had some pay it right away, some argue, some say they’ll pay and don’t. If they argue or go silent, I’ve gotten Airbnb involved at that point to resolve it. If it’s collecting a fine, they’ll contact the guest again on your behalf. If it’s damage claim, then Aircover gets involved to do a payout to you. I had a guest refuse to pay my fine and since it was clearly stated in my rules on Airbnb, Airbnb actually paid me the fine. Whether they collected that money later from the guest, I’m not sure. I guess those days of support from Airbnb will be long-gone once Nov 20th hits.

BTW, Aircover didn’t pay me all of what I was out...they only pay a percentage, which sucks. That’s why I started using Hospitable’s Protect on my bookings. I had two situations where I couldn’t get the items fixed before the next guest but Aircover required a “receipt” by the 14th day, so I had to just buy materials to fix it myself and show them the receipt. 


jtheuriet
Known Participant
Forum|alt.badge.img
  • Known Participant
  • Nov 18, 2026 6:16 PM UTC

​@Jilly how do you block a guest in Airbnb?


Jilly
Known Participant
Forum|alt.badge.img
  • Known Participant
  • Nov 18, 2026 6:32 PM UTC

​@Jilly how do you block a guest in Airbnb?

Not sure how to do it on mobile app, but on the website, you go into your Messages to go to the conversation with that Booker. At the top of the conversation is their name and profile photo with an arrow next to it. Click the arrow, then click their name to get into their profile. Once you’re in their profile, there’s an option to block or report them. Just click ‘block’.